Holly Howe
Rated 5 out of 5
We stayed just for a night on our way to Key West. The staff here are all so friendly, and the suites are nice and clean. We really enjoyed using the complimentary paddle-boards and kayaks. It’s nice and quiet too!



+119

1 King Bed and 1 Double Sofa Bed
Tropical Efficiency with Kitchen
1 King Bed and 1 Queen Bed
Suite, 2 Bedrooms, Kitchen (Royal Caribbean )
1 Queen Bed
Suite, Bay View (Tropical)
1 King Bed and 1 Double Sofa Bed
Cottage, Kitchen (with Tiki Hut Porch)
1 King Bed
Suite, 1 Bedroom, Kitchen (Caribbean Beach )
1 King Bed
Suite, Kitchen (Orchid)
1 King Bed and 1 Double Sofa Bed
Cottage, Bay View (Premium View with Tiki Porch)
1 Queen Bed
Basic Room, Refrigerator & Microwave, Courtyard Area (Heron )
2 King Beds
Deluxe Room (Deluxe Double King)
Located in the heart of the Florida Keys, Atlantic Bay Resort is a serene waterfront getaway in Tavernier offering stunning sunset views and private beach access. This intimate resort features cozy, tropically-inspired accommodations surrounded by lush gardens and swaying palms. Perfect for couples, families, or solo travelers, it’s an ideal home base for snorkeling, kayaking, or simply relaxing by the ocean. Enjoy a peaceful, laid-back atmosphere with modern comforts and authentic island charm.
4.8
562
Reviews
Atlantic Bay Resort consistently receives positive reviews, praised for its cleanliness, beautiful location, and relaxing atmosphere. Guests appreciate the included amenities like paddleboards and kayaks, as well as the friendly staff and stunning sunset views. While some minor issues with bed comfort have been noted, the overall experience is highly recommended.
Holly Howe
Rated 5 out of 5
We stayed just for a night on our way to Key West. The staff here are all so friendly, and the suites are nice and clean. We really enjoyed using the complimentary paddle-boards and kayaks. It’s nice and quiet too!
Kaylee Williams
Rated 5 out of 5
My family and I stayed at the Atlantic Bay Resort in June of this year. We had an AMAZING time. The rooms are updated and very clean, the units also keep cold in the Florida heat. There are places to fish along with dock your boat which we did for the 5 days we stayed. There’s also a pod of manatees that frequent the dock area. We took out the paddle-boards and kayaks and got to explore the mangroves. The staff were so nice and accommodating and were always great to chat with. The pool area was very clean and relaxing after a long day! Overall we had an amazing stay and will definitely be back!
Niki Moore
Rated 5 out of 5
What a great find! It's in a beautiful location with great facilities and our little bungalow was lovely. Free cycle and kayak rental and a great little breakfast. You won't be disappointed.
Orlando Collado Your Local Realtor
Rated 5 out of 5
????? Atlantic Bay Resort was a fantastic place to stay beautiful, relaxing, and exactly what we were looking for. The property was clean, well maintained, and the atmosphere made it easy to unwind and enjoy the Florida Keys. We had a great experience and would definitely stay here again!
Cecile
Rated 5 out of 5
Had the pleasure of staying one night for a Poler Run and what a great experience! Very clean and well cared for hotel and grounds. Would absolutely recommend for an extended stay as they have kitchens in all the suites. Only 2 things: the bed was a bit soft for us and unfortunately there is nothing open past 10pm anywhere near. Make sure you do some groceries before arriving!!
Rico Razzo
Rated 5 out of 5
The pictures on the website don’t really do this place justice, it really is terrific and tremendous value for money - the view across the bay is spectacular, there’s a lovely air of relaxation about the place, it’s quiet and relaxed, rooms are really good. There’s kayaks and bikes to use, and a couple of restaurants nearby within walking distance. Service friendly. Definite place to stop.
Jack Eastland
Rated 4 out of 5
To me, the most important thing about a resort is comfort. This little resort is precious. Perfectly clean and everyone was nice. HOWEVER-I’m literally in physical pain because the beds were so awful. We got off our cruise after 8 beautiful days in a big soft bed, only to have to sleep on springs. Do better Atlantic Bay Resort! Some inexpensive toppers would make all the difference.
Olivia Oltrogge
Rated 5 out of 5
Absolutely gorgeous!!! Perfect place to relax. Free kayaks, paddle boards and bicycles just need to sign them out. Went for our honeymoon and can't wait to come back!!!!
Marine Stanley
Rated 5 out of 5
I cannot recommend this place enough, my husband and I came for our short honeymoon and everything was absolutely perfect. The environment they have built and the Cottages, we couldn’t have wished a better place to stay. I highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a place in the area. We will be back
Tom Hackett
Rated 5 out of 5
Lilly was great. The entire place was magical and what I always thought and hoped a small resort in the Keys would be. Nothing but 5's from my wife and I.
Key Largo