Bayside Villas by Islander Resort check-in/check-out kiosk
Bayside Villas by Islander Resort room
Bayside Villas by Islander Resort – photo 4 of 58

+54

Bayside Villas by Islander Resort building design

Rooms

  • Queen/Queen Bedroom ADA

    2 Queen Beds and 1 Double Sofa Bed

    Brand New Queen/Queen Bedroom ADA

  • Two King Bed Preferred

    2 King Beds and 1 Double Sofa Bed

    Brand New Two King Bed Preferred

  • Two King Bay Front

    2 King Beds and 1 Double Sofa Bed

    Brand New Two King Bay Front

  • Two King Bedroom Bay View

    2 King Beds and 1 Double Sofa Bed

    Brand New Two King Bedroom Bay View

  • Two King Bed Standard

    2 King Beds and 1 Double Sofa Bed

    Brand New Two King Bed Standard

Property Overview

Islander Bayside & Oceanside presents a serene escape where coastal elegance and tropical charm converge. Surrounded by the natural beauty of Islamorada, this refined retreat offers an elevated experience infused with island sophistication. Each detail reflects a harmonious blend of modern style and relaxed ambiance, creating the perfect backdrop for unforgettable moments. Discover the art of effortless luxury in the heart of the Florida Keys.

  • Pets allowed with a fee
  • Water activities
  • On-site parking
  • Area shuttle

Amenities

Activities

  • Beach Access
  • Beach volleyball
  • Bicycle rentals
  • Events allowed
  • Outdoor pool
  • Yoga classes

Business services

  • Meeting rooms

Food and drink

  • Bar/lounge
  • Kitchen/Kitchenette
  • Restaurants
  • Wedding services

Parking

  • Self parking (surcharge)

Property services

  • Accessible property
  • Pets allowed with a fee

Shuttles and transportation

  • Area shuttle (surcharge)

Bathroom

  • Hair dryer

Bedding and linens

  • Sofa bed

Features

  • Balcony
  • In-room climate (air conditioning)
  • In-room climate control (heating)
  • Iron/ironing board
  • Private entrance

Media and electronics

  • Phone
  • Television
  • WiFi (surcharge)

Policies & key facts

Check-in
Check-out
Parking
Available for a feeSelf parking (surcharge)
Pets
AllowedPets allowed with a fee
Accessibility
Accessible property

Reviews

4.4

292

Reviews

Bayside Villas by Islander Resort receives mixed reviews, with recent guests praising the spacious villas, convenient marina access, and helpful staff like Allison. However, older reviews highlight maintenance issues, cleanliness concerns, and plumbing problems within the units. Despite the occasional shortcomings, many guests appreciate the resort’s amenities and family-friendly atmosphere.

  • Spacious villas
  • Convenient marina access
  • Helpful staff (Allison)
  • Family-friendly atmosphere
  • Bay views
Cleanliness
3 out of 5
Location
4 out of 5
Value
3.5 out of 5
Service
4 out of 5
Amenities
4 out of 5
  1. Nele Reiners

    Rated 3 out of 5

    The Villas are really nice and provide everything one needs, but the overall experience was not up to par. We were really confused upon arrival, because check-in was actually half a mile up the road at the ‘real’ Islander resort. We were the only ones then in this Villa part of the hotel, then after one night other guests came that had a loud barking dog and were placed directly in the villa next to ours, which was totally unnecessary. Later, I forgot shoes in a bedroom, knew exactly where they were, but the lost-and-found experience was truly lacking. I had sent an email with the details, no reply. I sent another one to another address, that address was no longer valid. I called, the person who answered knew exactly what I was talking about and said the shoes were not found… that’s a really weird thing. First the hotel could have replied to or called me, and then I just don’t believe that the shoes weren’t found. Yes, definitely my own fault for not packing properly, but at a resort of this standard and price I really expect better. To be honest due to this I would consider other places to stay.

  2. Karen DeLeo

    Rated 5 out of 5

    We truly enjoyed our stay at Bayside Villas and will be back! The villa was roomy, clean, and had comfortable beds. DJ Nick did a great job shuttling us around and was always prompt and friendly. Chris and Jada at Tides and Drift restaurants were the best! Food was delicious! This location is perfect for us to bring our boat and go lobstering. Had a blast!

  3. petra neues

    Rated 5 out of 5

    stayed at the marina side, great quiet cozy beachy town house like apts with upstairs balcony, great views, comfortable living room, super compfy 2 bedrooms upstairs, big TV, full kitchen (ask what to bring if you plan on cooking a lot or for many people for e.g a strainer, large cooking pot etc ) - was not an issue for me though, publix is also just down the road for shopping, very clean and nice conditioner shampoo soap etc the dock/private marina is 10 sec walk from all of the suites and a pool with a view that is to die for. staff was super friendly but everything was already so perfect I never had to call :)

  4. Jaffo

    Rated 5 out of 5

    This was our first time staying at the bayside villas and first time in the keys. Great experience! The villas are a great option for families who want a little more space, but be together, and also have access to the main resort amenities. A pretty good price point for 4 people. William got us reservations at a great restaurant down the street and after hearing we were going to Miami after, even reached out to some contacts to see if he could get a good deal for us at a hotel there. He went above and beyond. Thank you!

  5. Maria Varela

    Rated 5 out of 5

    Stayed at the villas for 4 nights and had a blast! Rooms are pet friendly and spacious. Perfect spot for us and our two dogs. You get access to the main resort which is recently renovated and super nice! William assisted us with checking out and brought all of our luggage to the car. Looking forward to coming back in August!!!

  6. Andrea Horst

    Rated 5 out of 5

    We had a great time at the villas. We had Islander resort amenities (that they shuttle you to, less than a mile away) with the space we needed for a family of five. The staff were so kind and helpful. The front desk concierge at the villas bayside was amazing. She truly made our experience exceptional. If you go to the resort, Xixi the hostess at the restaurant couldn’t be kinder and more personable. We loved chatting with her every morning. We had Renee twice as a server and she was wonderful. We loved it so much we booked to go back before we left!

  7. Suzanne Rausch

    Rated 5 out of 5

    If you are going to Islamorada… definitely check out Bayside Villas ( Islander ) great to keep the travel party together to enjoy group time! The units are comfortable and clean and the pool has great views! Plus use of the sister property so you get more of the energetic vibes plus amenities for your use!!!

  8. A M

    Rated 2 out of 5

    We stayed for 5 nights at the villas. The size of the villa and convenience of having a full kitchen is great, as well as the bay views. Other than that, it wasn’t the greatest stay. It is very clear the property is often neglected maintenance and cleanliness wise, particularly in comparison to the full Islander Resort. Our body wash was empty upon arrival and never refilled our entire stay. The pool towels were constantly empty and we had to go seek out an employee (not an easy task here) every day for them to be refilled. The lounge chairs and outdoor day beds were never straightened up or cleaned on the property. The kayaks were taken out by guests our first day here and never returned, so we were never able to use them. Several people had dogs, but weren’t the best at cleaning up after them, and no employee is there to maintain things. The wi-fi was so bad, we had to just use cellular, and the signal is iffy. Our last full day, the cleaning crew came in and took our washcloths and floor towels and didn’t replace them with clean ones. We called down (with our personal cell phones since the provided phone in the villa didn’t work) but the front office at the villas doesn’t have an employee on site after 4:00/5:00, so we had to call the Islander resort to bring them over. It took over an hour for them to arrive and they just handed us a huge trash bag filled with towels. If there were a full time employee or two on site at the villas maintaining the property, it would make a massive difference. For the price, $800+ a night, we expected a lot more.

  9. YoSoyJuanCarlos

    Rated 5 out of 5

    Great couple day escape from Miami! We loved the room. Very peaceful right on the bay. William was great! Very friendly and even went out of his way to drive down the road after we checked out to deliver something we forgot. Thank you for a great trip!!

  10. Are Castillo

    Rated 5 out of 5

    William took great care of us! Top tier service. We would come back just for him! The rooms are great and we enjoyed sitting out on the balcony overlooking the bay. The restaurant at the islander resort was delicious along with the other restaurants William gave as recommendations. The shuttles were extremely convenient to have. Our drivers were always very friendly.??????

Map

Islamorada

Property Address
81450 Overseas Highway
Islamorada
Property Contact
305-664-0082
Powered byRipe