Coconut Cay Resort & Marina room
Coconut Cay Resort & Marina room
Coconut Cay Resort & Marina room

+3

Coconut Cay Resort & Marina exterior

Rooms

  • Standard Room, 2 Queen Beds, Patio, Canal View

    2 Queen Beds

    Standard Room, 2 Queen Beds, Patio, Canal View

  • Standard Studio, 2 Queen Beds, Kitchen, Canal View

    2 Queen Beds

    Standard Studio, 2 Queen Beds, Kitchen, Canal View

  • Deluxe Double Room, 2 Queen Beds

    2 Queen Beds

    Deluxe Double Room, 2 Queen Beds

  • Deluxe King Room Pool View

    1 King Bed

    Deluxe King Room Pool View

  • Standard Room, 1 King Bed

    1 King Bed

    Standard Room, 1 King Bed

  • Deluxe King Room

    1 King Bed

    Deluxe King Room

Property Overview

Coconut Cay Resort & Marina offers a laid-back tropical escape in the heart of the Florida Keys, perfect for relaxation and adventure. Guests can enjoy colorful, island-inspired accommodations, a private marina, and easy access to fishing, boating, and water sports. The resort’s inviting outdoor spaces, including a pool and picnic areas, create the ideal setting for a memorable Florida Keys getaway.

  • Waterfront location with private marina access
  • Complimentary use of kayaks and bicycles
  • Pet-friendly accommodations
  • Close to fishing charters, beaches, and local attractions

Amenities

Food and drink

  • Barbecue grill(s)
  • Picnic area
  • Coffee/tea in common areas
  • Free breakfast
  • Wedding services
  • Microwave
  • Mini-fridge

Property services

  • Front desk (limited hours)
  • Tours/ticket assistance
  • Pool sun loungers
  • Luggage storage
  • Designated smoking areas (fines apply)
  • Laundry facility - coin operated
  • Beach towels
  • Multilingual staff
  • Free newspapers in lobby

Parking

  • Free self parking
  • Free RV, bus, truck parking

Activities

  • Private beach nearby
  • Outdoor pool
  • Outdoor pool (surcharge)

Business services

  • Computer station

Features

  • Air conditioning
  • Soundproofed rooms
  • Iron/ironing board (on request)
  • Private bathroom
  • Private bathroom (not in room)
  • Hair dryer (on request)
  • Shower only

Internet access in public areas

  • Free WiFi
  • Free WiFi (limited) device count
  • Free WiFi (limited) duration
  • Free WiFi (limited) time

Services

  • Daily housekeeping

Bathroom

  • Towels provided
  • Free toiletries
  • Hair dryer

Media and electronics

  • Ceiling fan
  • Television
  • Television (surcharge)
  • Cable TV service
  • Flat-panel TV

Policies & key facts

Check-in
Check-out
Parking
IncludedFree self parking · Free RV, bus, truck parking
Smoking
Designated smoking areas (fines apply)

Reviews

4.2

1715

Reviews

Coconut Cay Resort & Marina receives mixed reviews, with many guests praising its excellent location, affordability, and the availability of complimentary water sports equipment. However, several recent reviews highlight issues with cleanliness, inconsistent staff service, and unexpected fees, as well as concerns about unpleasant odors and the marina’s condition. Overall, the property offers a good value for the Keys, but recent problems need addressing.

  • Free water sports equipment (kayaks, paddleboards, bikes)
  • Good location for exploring the Keys
  • Affordable prices
  • Friendly staff (occasionally)
  • Close proximity to restaurants and attractions
Cleanliness
3 out of 5
Location
4.5 out of 5
Value
4 out of 5
Service
3.5 out of 5
Amenities
4 out of 5
  1. Victor Kresge

    Rated 5 out of 5

    Perfect spot for me. The layout reminds me of the days when vacation was for fun and relaxing not noise and rushing. The rooms were very clean, quiet , and spacious. All of the helpers were very friendly. The girls at the front desk could not be nicer. Plenty of towels, just ask if you need more. Prices were reasonable, equipped with a refrigerator, microwave, and a coffee maker, need more just ask and the girls will see you get it. Looking to another stay soon.

  2. A C

    Rated 1 out of 5

    ????? A total nightmare. Never again. Our stay at Coconut Cay Resort & Marina was miserable. The room floors were sticky, and the air conditioning barely worked properly. The grounds smelled bad, with chicken droppings all over the place. I understand chickens are part of the Keys, but there is no excuse for neglecting basic cleanliness. They never told us the pool was out of service and offered no discount for the unavailable amenity. Housekeeping opened our room door without knocking, showing a complete disregard for our privacy. The manager was rude, and the staff’s poor communication made dealing with these problems even more frustrating. Then they charged us for keeping our boat overnight at their dock when we NEVER did. At the front desk, I also witnessed another customer disputing three credit card charges and other guests questioning charges for things they said they had never used. That was deeply concerning, especially while we were dealing with our own incorrect charge. We paid for a relaxing vacation and ended up uncomfortable, frustrated, and feeling cheated. I regret spending my money here. We will never return, and I strongly recommend staying elsewhere. If you have already stayed here, check every charge on your bill.

  3. Deborah Corbett

    Rated 5 out of 5

    We only stayed one night but the room was very clean, the beds were comfy and the water pressure really good. There's a small coffee maker, fridge and microwave. The pool area was clean with lots of seating. In the Keys, so a lot of ? ?; part of the charm. Great location and plenty of parking. We loved the hammocks everywhere.

  4. Karye Martin

    Rated 5 out of 5

    This place was fantastic. It was booked very last minute and the price was excellent the location was perfect we had our own paddle boards but the property offered paddle boards and kayaks and life jackets as well as bikes free of charge. We went directly out on our paddle boards right from the property and it was super easy the water have lots of fish and Jellyfish it was a beautiful area if you wanted to go exploring with your family. This was a 2-day family vacation two adults and two teenagers. I highly recommend staying here for anyone that loves the keys & being out on the water. The room had everything we needed including a microwave & mini fridge.

  5. Mark Gadala-Maria

    Rated 1 out of 5

    STAY AWAY. Massive “surprise” fees, horrific smells, rude and incompetent staff, and a barely usable marina. The worst hotel experience I’ve had in the U.S. after 100 hotels nationwide. Before booking, I called about a room and dock slip. I was told a “Canal View” room, $120/night more, included a slip and trailer parking. I booked, called back, and was told everything was secured. The morning of my trip, I was told the policy had changed and it would now cost another $100/night. “May,” “Jocelyn,” and “Deonna” were rude, condescending, and blamed me for not knowing. I could no longer cancel. At reception I said “good afternoon” and Deonna replied, “Okay.” Jocelyn reduced the scam fee by 50%, which I reluctantly paid. Deonna then spent 20 minutes looking for my key. The room smelled like raw sewage. My friends’ room on the other side smelled the same. It was dirty, the sheets were stained, the TV didn’t work, and the sticky remote was disgusting. The walls were paper thin, we heard our neighbors, and loud roosters woke us at 5 AM every morning. The marina is terrible. They pack in as many boats as possible, the canal is extremely tight, and parking is difficult. Without 20+ years of boating experience, it would have been daunting. There are no cleats, only old pilings, and the dock is severely rotted and full of splinters that got into my hands and feet. This may be the worst-managed hotel in the Florida Keys. Save your time, money, and headache and stay elsewhere.

  6. Eric Feliz

    Rated 5 out of 5

    The location, price, amenities, and rooms were all phenomenal. I will be staying again. I stayed here and had booked 2 different rooms for different nights and each was amazing in its own way. They have free kayaking and biking and a pretty decent fishing spot. We stayed at the room by the dock and it was a worthy experience. Wake up and you can see the water from the sliding door, fish right from your own back patio (although by the mangroves is better). Definitely worth the price, especially since it's about a 5-10 minute drive from a lot of stuff.

  7. Timothy Wahl

    Rated 5 out of 5

    This was my brides and my first time to the Keys. Coconut Cay was located perfectly between the fast paced Key West and the slower paced Key Largo with many Keys in between to explore. It was quiet, our room was perfect, with fresh towels and sheets. Service from the front desk was friendly and exceptional. Any questions we had or requests were handled immediately and to full satisfaction. The pool was a great was to loosen up before we went riding and exploring for the day or a great way to relax once we’d returned. Overall 10/10 and would be back to stay again.

  8. Brian Noel

    Rated 4 out of 5

    If you're looking for cheaper, clean rooms, this is your spot. If you're looking for a spa day and infinity swimming pool maybe not. We didn't have much interactions with the staff but when they did they were friendly and helpful. They have a bunch of different equipment to use like bikes, etc. The AC in the room worked extremely well, I just wish it was quieter. The furniture is older but totally fine. The bed was comfortable. The shower was fine. It's very close to the highway but I guess the loud AC drowned out the traffic noise. You could definitely hear traffic pass by. It's also next to an an air strip. So if you stay at the hotel itself, you will hear planes. Navy helicopters were circling for a while too but there's a Naval base nearby as well so it can't be helped. There also weren't any open power outlets, and we didn't have the proper cables so we had to plug our phones in, in the bathroom. Again not a huge deal.

  9. Jami Jackson

    Rated 5 out of 5

    We had such a wonderful stay at Coconut Bay in Marathon during spring break with our two 10-year-old boys. It was truly everything we needed for a relaxing and fun family getaway. The room was clean, the beds were incredibly soft, and the air conditioning worked perfectly (which is a must in the Florida heat!). From the moment we arrived, the staff made us feel welcome—everyone was friendly and accommodating, especially Alex, who went above and beyond to make our stay even better. One of the things we appreciated most was the thoughtful amenities. Being able to sign out fresh beach towels each day was so convenient. Our boys had an absolute blast biking along the sidewalks, swimming in the pool, kayaking, fishing off the marina, and relaxing in the hammock. The option to borrow fishing poles was such a nice touch—we even left behind some hooks and weights for future guests to enjoy. What really stood out to us was the atmosphere. It never felt restrictive or overly “rule-heavy”—instead, it felt easygoing and welcoming, which made all the difference when traveling with kids. Everything we needed was right there at a reasonable price, and we left feeling refreshed and grateful. A huge thank you to Coconut Bay for such a memorable stay. We will absolutely be back and will be recommending it to everyone we know traveling down from Delaware!

  10. Chris Wieland

    Rated 4 out of 5

    Coconut Cay is a nice small older motel that serves Marathon, Fl. While not cheap, it is less expensive than other hotels/motels in Marathon. The rooms are spotless and well maintained. The bed was excellent. Access to the interior courtyard and pool was through a sliding door; there were chairs and a small table on a small patio at each room. Furniture is a bit dated, but perfectly fine. The staff was very helpful and professional. We had a sticky lock on the door and asked for a repair, which occurred within 10 minutes of our request. Coconut Cay provides customers access to kayaks, paddleboards and bicycles at no additional cost - a real rarity for the the Keys. I recommend it for budget conscious travelers.

Map

Marathon

Property Address
7196 Overseas Highway
Marathon
Property Contact
305-289-7672
Powered byRipe